In Their Words

The world they lived through

Where were you when you heard about a major historical event — 9/11, the moon landing, a president being shot?

Why this question matters

Where-were-you-when questions land in a particular part of memory — the part that captures rooms, weather, and the exact phrasing of who said what. Your parents lived through events you only know secondhand, and their lived version is always more textured than the documentary. The detail they remember is rarely the headline; it is the thing happening alongside it.

If they pause, try this

Ask what the world felt like in the days after — how people around them reacted.

What people often remember when asked this

  • 01

    Most parents will give you a specific room and a specific time of day. Don't rush past it. Ask who was with them, what they were doing right before, and whether anyone said something that has stuck.

  • 02

    For traumatic events, listen for what they noticed about other people in the room. Often the part they remember most clearly is somebody else's reaction — a parent crying, a stranger praying, a stranger trying to keep working as if nothing had happened.

  • 03

    For the moon landing and other wonder events, ask what the next morning felt like. The days after a moment of collective awe tend to have their own quiet glow that nobody talks about.

A small tip for the conversation

After the first event, ask if there is a second one — something smaller that the rest of the country has forgotten but they still remember exactly where they were. The smaller one often produces the richer story.

Related questions

← Back to questions about the world they lived through